Skip to main content

AN INTEGRATED ANALYSIS WITH LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT, BUILDING INFORMATION MODELING, AND ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE FOR WINDOW MATERIALS: ASSIUT UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL CLINIC AS A CASE STUDY

Research Abstract
The main goal of this study is to undertake the three methods of life cycle assessment (LCA), the environmental performance (EP), and the building information modeling (BIM) to determine the environmental performance and impacts of two window frame materials: aluminum and wood. This study has been carried out in a proposed project at the Assiut University campus. The LCA has been conducted by assessing materials and processes involved in manufacturing the two window frame types using the SimaPro. The LCA scope of this research covers from cradle to the gate with a designated system boundary. The network flow has been drawn to produce one kilogram of aluminum and wood; the quantities data were gathered from the BIM (using Autodesk Revit). Selecting the database is carefully picked from the Ecoinvent dataset to be closer to Egypt's manufacturing processes. Afterwards, the IMPACT 2002+ with midpoint and endpoint calculations has been used. Finally, the LCA results have been compared with the EP results (using DesignBuilder) to determine the best choice between the two materials. The integration analysis shows that the aluminum industry has higher negative environmental impacts and environmental performance than the wood industry. The total midpoint results of the two materials are found to be 29.6 for aluminum, and 7.57 the wood. Turning to the endpoint results, human health and resource depletion impacts are the most significant results. The human health scored the highest value, with 13.9 for aluminum and 3.51 for wood. A novel framework for integrating LCA, BIM, and EP for a proposed building during the early phases of a project has been conducted in this study. The presented study can be used as a model for integrating comparative analysis on other proposed projects as the LCA applications in Egypt are scarce due to the absence of a reliable database. This study has introduced a value applying an approach to select the appropriate life cycle inventory database from the Ecoinvent dataset. The research findings contribute to choosing the most suitable window frame materials with the most energy-efficient effect and the least environmental burden. Moreover, it can help the concerned legislative bodies and the decision-makers.
Research Authors
Ahmed AbdelMonteleb Mohammed Ali
Research Journal
JES Journal of Engineering Science
Research Pages
1024-1050
Research Publisher
JES Journal of Engineering Science
Research Rank
2
Research Vol
Article 2, Volume 48, No 6, November and December 2020
Research Website
https://jesaun.journals.ekb.eg/article_116730.html
Research Year
2020

Multi-criteria selection of high-performance glazing systems: A case study of an office building in New Cairo, Egypt

Research Abstract
The energy consumption of fully glazed office buildings is very high due to the heavy cooling loads in summer. Therefore, building designers resort to the High-Performance Glazing System (HPGS) solutions to reduce solar heat gain and save energy. However, the selection of most sustainable HPGS is considered a complicated process because the one criterion decision method - which building designers still tend to use - cannot solve this complexity. Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) analysis can solve this problem and rank the alternatives. In this paper, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) - one of the MCDM methods - is applied by SuperDecisions software to rank three proposed HPGS alternatives for an existing office building in New Cairo, Egypt as a case study in a hot desert climate zone. Four criteria of sustainability (energy, environmental impacts, cost, and occupant comfort) are assessed and a new weighting method is applied based on LEED rating system to prioritize the alternatives. The ranking results show in the first place the Photovoltaic glazing system followed by the Low-E and Electrochromic glazing systems, respectively with a negligible difference. The Life cycle cost criterion is the major influencer on the ranking results according to the applied sensitivity analysis.
Research Authors
Youssef O Elkhayat, Mona G Ibrahim, Koji Tokimatsu, Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M Ali
Research Journal
Journal of Building Engineering

Research Pages
101466
Research Publisher
Elsevier
Research Rank
1
Research Vol
Volume 32, November 2020
Research Website
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2352710220302849
Research Year
2020

A comparative life cycle assessment of three high-performance glazing systems for office buildings in a hot desert climate zone

Research Abstract
In hot desert climates, the office buildings with high-performance glazing systems (HPGSs) provide better indoor thermal and visual comfort to the occupants due to the advanced coatings which prevent the undesired heat gain and daylight. However, these systems save energy in the use phase; it could consume more energy in the pre-use and post-use phases. Furthermore, the use of advanced materials may have negative impacts on the environment. Therefore, this paper selected the comparative life cycle assessment method as an environmental measuring tool to compare the energy consumption and the environmental impacts of three HPGSs with that of the conventional clear double-glazing system. The results show that the photovoltaic glazing system (PVGS) has the lowest energy consumption and the lowest environmental impacts, followed by the electrochromic glazing system (ECGS) and the low-E glazing system. In the use phase, both PVGS and ECGS achieved the highest energy savings, 87% and 25%, respectively. The use phase has a major contribution to the energy consumption and environmental impacts, while the pre-use and post-use phases have insignificant contributions in this study. The results could support decision-makers in choosing the most environmentally friendly HPGS for their projects.
Research Authors
Youssef O. Elkhayat, Mona G. Ibrahim, Koji Tokimatsu & Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M. Ali
Research Journal
Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy
Research Pages
1499–1515
Research Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Research Rank
1
Research Vol
Volume 22, Issue 7
Research Website
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10098-020-01891-2
Research Year
2020

Life cycle cost analysis on three high-performance glazing systems for an office building in New Cairo, Egypt

Research Abstract
In the hot desert climate zones, the energy consumption of fully glazed office buildings is too high due to the heavy cooling loads. This problem forced architects to use the High-Performance Glazing Systems (HPGSs) which reduce the solar heat gain and save energy. Despite the high initial cost, the HPGSs are supposed to be economically feasible in the long term. This study investigates and compares the economic feasibility of three HPGSs for an office building in New Cairo. In terms of life cycle cost (LCC), the Low-E, Electrochromic, and Photovoltaic glazing systems are compared to the Clear Double-Glazing as a conventional system. Furthermore, the three economic indicators; Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), and Payback Period (PBP) are analysed. In conclusion, the Low-E Glazing System has the lowest LCC because of the low disposal cost. Moreover, the Low-E glazing has the highest NPV, IRR, and the shortest PBP (15 years). Due to the high initial and maintenance costs, the Photovoltaic Glazing System has a higher LCC. The Electrochromic Glazing System is not economically feasible due to the highest LCC, the lowest NPV, the lowest IRR, and the longest PBP which exceeds 30 years.
Research Authors
Youssef O Elkhayat, Mona G Ibrahim, Koji Tokimatsu, Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M Ali
Research Journal
Architectural Engineering and Design Management
Research Pages
Pages 131-145
Research Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Research Rank
1
Research Vol
Volume 17, 2021 - Issue 1-2
Research Website
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17452007.2020.1788500
Research Year
2020

Assessment of eco-rehabilitation plans: Case study ‘Richordi Berchet’palace

Research Abstract
Setting eco-rehabilitation plans for cultural heritage buildings require robust guidelines and assessment mechanism to account for the reuse scenarios as well as the construction and demolition waste management plans (C&D-WMPs). This is problematic with the existence of numerous environmental assessment methods. Nevertheless, it is noted that the majority of building rehabilitation practices pay more concern towards the physical properties of materials rather than their environmental value. Hence, this study provides insights for using two different assessment methods in this regard; ‘Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design’ (LEED) and ‘Life Cycle Assessment’ (LCA). The study adopts a cross-comparative quantitative methodology using a practical case study analysis- ‘Richordi Berchet’ palace - the oldest historic LEED Gold certified building. It investigates the efficiency of LEED materials’ credits to support sustainable building reuse and set C&D-WMPs. Noting that these credits operate in quite a simplistic and abstract manner based on materials’ physical properties; weight, area or volume, hence, the LCA method is used to account for their environmental profile expressed in embodied carbon and embodied energy. This pinpoints cases where the use of LEED measurement criteria provides acceptable results and others where the use of LCA is necessary to yield reliable results-noting that their marginal percentage difference is estimated to be ±15%. This indicates the mutual benefit of integrating LCA to support LEED materials credits in such a way that achieves relevance and reliability of eco-building rehabilitation plans. This aims at bridging the gap between researchers and practitioners’ best practices. It also provides insights for green building rating systems developers to consider the environmental value of sustainable rehabilitation guidelines and set reliable measurement and evaluation mechanism.
Research Authors
Walaa SE Ismaeel, Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M Ali
Research Journal
Journal of Cleaner Production
Research Pages
1-12
Research Publisher
ELSEVIER
Research Rank
1
Research Vol
Volume 259, 20 June 2020, 120857
Research Website
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0959652620309045
Research Year
2020

Development of Green Building Materials’ Evaluation Criteria to Achieve Optimum Building Facade Energy Performance

Research Abstract
Since buildings and their construction materials exploit natural resources as well as the effect on energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions, evaluating building materials is needed to have more sustainable buildings. This study proposes a methodology to define the proper selection of green building materials that can be used for building façades; whilst taking its thermal performance and energy efficiency into account. Additionally, the study compared the energy consumption for six conventional materials for two types of buildings (Educational, Residential) in four climate zones using a simulation program (DesignBuilder). It included also the embodied carbon and equivalent CO 2 for different types of used external façades materials. The evaluation and results is an important step to identify the suitable material that could be replaced with green material and determine how it performs in terms of simulation results and matching with the proposed criteria. The results show enhancement of thermal comfort when replacing a conventional material Brickwork with an environmentally friendly one (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Block). Moreover, it has a positive impact regarding sub-criteria (from the proposed framework). However, the proposed green material couldn't achieve the expected performance regarding energy performance (as it achieved a minor enhancement from 3245.07 to 3239.1 KWh, U-value for both materials is close) or embodied energy (as the increase of kgCO2 from 758 to 1649.3 due to cement which is one of its ingredients).
Research Authors
Marwa M Gomaa Mayhoub, Mona G Ibrahim, Zeyad M Tarek El Sayad, Ahmed Abdel Monteleb M Ali
Research Journal
2019 International Conference on Sustainable Energy Engineering and Application (ICSEEA)
Research Pages
1-8
Research Publisher
IEEE
Research Rank
3
Research Vol
23 December 2019
Research Website
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8938620
Research Year
2019

Environmental Analysis of a Day-care Building in Egypt by Life cycle Assessment tool

Research Abstract
This paper aims to measure the footprint for construction materials and construction and demolition waste (CDW) environmental impacts for a case study building in Egypt through the complete Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of the building ‘from cradle to grave’. The LCA measures eight impact categories, including carbon emissions and energy demand. Our analysis demonstrates the relative importance of life cycle stages; construction processes and materials manufacturing that make the largest contributions to the buildings’ environmental impacts. The results show that the material manufacturing stage is the most critical stage because of its high contribution (about 70%) of the total environmental impacts. On the other hand the disposal stage contributes (about -10%). The results can help engineers and construction industry stakeholders in Egypt to use more sustainable construction materials and change their CDW management practice.
Research Authors
Sara Hassan S. Abdelhalem; Nady Mustafa A. Amri; Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M. Ali.
Research Journal
JES Journal of Engineering Science
Research Pages
Page 538-550
Research Publisher
JES Journal of Engineering Science
Research Rank
2
Research Vol
Volume 47, No 4, July and August 2019
Research Website
https://jesaun.journals.ekb.eg/article_115511.html
Research Year
2019

Environmental Analysis of a Day-care Building in Egypt by Life cycle Assessment tool

Research Abstract
This paper aims to measure the footprint for construction materials and construction and demolition waste (CDW) environmental impacts for a case study building in Egypt through the complete Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of the building ‘from cradle to grave’. The LCA measures eight impact categories, including carbon emissions and energy demand. Our analysis demonstrates the relative importance of life cycle stages; construction processes and materials manufacturing that make the largest contributions to the buildings’ environmental impacts. The results show that the material manufacturing stage is the most critical stage because of its high contribution (about 70%) of the total environmental impacts. On the other hand the disposal stage contributes (about -10%). The results can help engineers and construction industry stakeholders in Egypt to use more sustainable construction materials and change their CDW management practice.
Research Authors
Sara Hassan S. Abdelhalem; Nady Mustafa A. Amri; Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M. Ali.
Research Journal
JES Journal of Engineering Science
Research Pages
Page 538-550
Research Publisher
JES Journal of Engineering Science
Research Rank
2
Research Vol
Volume 47, No 4, July and August 2019
Research Website
https://jesaun.journals.ekb.eg/article_115511.html
Research Year
2019

Improving the functional performance of outdoor spaces in hot arid region using photovoltaics systems

Research Abstract
There is a rapid increasing in the deployment of photovoltaic but most of its installations are on building facades and roofs. Therefore, to achieve the needed large-scale integration of photovoltaic into our energy system will require large-scale deployment beyond the building scale, which will become a part of our landscape. This paper seeks to improve the functional performance of outdoor spaces through the potential of power generation by photovoltaic in outdoor spaces, in hot regions, and improving the thermal comfort. Site measurements, survey, interviews, a 3D model of a shading device using DesignBuilder software, and Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations were developed as part of the study. A comparison was made between the obtained measurements and simulation outputs for validation. The methodology is demonstrated for a case-study in Borg El Arab New City, Alexandria, Egypt. The simulation shows that the installation of PV, on the rooftop and the South-West elevation, enhanced the thermal comfort, and generated three and half times the annual consumed power for lighting, laptop charging units, and Wi-Fi hotspot. The results show that the installations of photovoltaic on shading device will promote the function of outdoor spaces, concerning the technological devices, and will suffice the need for energy for different outdoor needs.
Research Authors
Lucienne G Basaly, Mona G Ibrahim, Nancy Mahmoud Badawy, Mohammad Refaat M Abdelaal, Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M Ali
Research Journal
2019 Advances in Science and Engineering Technology International Conferences (ASET)
Research Pages
1-5
Research Publisher
IEEE
Research Rank
1
Research Vol
16 May 2019
Research Website
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8714508
Research Year
2019

An integrated assessment of the high-performance glazing systems in the office buildings

Research Abstract
The study focuses on comparing between three of the high-performance glazing systems (HPGS) available in the market through a simulation of a case study of an office building which is located in New Cairo City in Egypt as a hot desert climate zone. The paper aims to enable the decision makers to select the most suitable HPGS through an integrated assessment which combines between the energy, environmental and economic performances assessment. A clear double-glazing system is used as a basic scenario for benchmarking and compared to the three HPGS scenarios (Passive, Active and Building Integrated Photovoltaic BIPV). An office building model has been implemented by DesignBuilder software to illustrate how this assessment can be applied on a real architectural project. The results show that considering the three performances (environmental, energy and economic) in the integrated assessment can outweigh a scenario at the expense of another one. Although the BIPV has advantages in the energy performance, it has the highest embodied carbon. The Electro-chromic glass has the worst economic performance, however the building lowest CO 2 production. Low-E is the most suitable glazing system for the office buildings in the hot desert climate as it has achieved the highest accumulative points.
Research Authors
oussef O Elkhayat, Mona G Ibrahim, Ahmed AbdelMonteleb M Ali
Research Journal
2019 Advances in Science and Engineering Technology International Conferences (ASET)
Research Pages
1-6
Research Publisher
IEEE
Research Rank
1
Research Vol
16 May 2019
Research Website
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8714570
Research Year
2019
Subscribe to